You are reading

Methods for iTunes Organization

I mentioned a couple weeks ago that I was going to take some time to document my iTunes organization methods here soon, and the time has finally come. I know that for a lot of folks, this kind of stuff isn’t that interesting, but for anyone using iTunes as their primary digital music player with a somewhat extensive library it can be fun to nerd out a bit on it. Everyone has a different method and I’m always interested to hear how other people organize their files and manage their meta-data.

So let’s begin with the display: how things look for me in iTunes. As you can see above, I only use the Name, Year, Track, Time, Artist, Album by Artist (though I mix that up sometimes depending on how I want to browse), Grouping and Bit Rate view options. They’re the most pertinent for me, and I like to keep that part simple. I was never really sure what to use Grouping for, and a couple years ago I decided I’d use it for record label. It’s turned out to be an incredible tool — I can search by record label and create easy playlists that way. For example, it was fairly recently we had people over and I searched for “Dischord” and had a pretty kick ass Dischord-only playlist going. Though in recent years many labels have started to diversify enough that a playlist based on that criteria isn’t necessarily that fun, if you started getting into records in the ’90s like I did, it’s super rad. A Dischord, K or Vermiform playlist can rock your shit off. Of course there are older labels like Harvest that are fun to shuffle through. Do you use Grouping? If so, how do you use it?

Another thing I’m pretty particular about is album art. Nothing goes in iTunes without album art. If it’s a single song on its own, I use the whole album’s cover art. If it’s from the web or otherwise doesn’t have any particular art associated with it, I find a photo of the band or something from a MySpace or website. I’ll get into playlists and mixtapes later. I wasn’t always this neurotic about the album art — one weekend I decided I couldn’t stand it anymore and went through and fixed all of it. iTunes actually has a decent tool for importing artwork that can find most stuff, but it’s not perfect. For a lot of ’70s and ’80s stuff I had in the library as straggler singles, it worked perfectly, though. More obscure shit, you need to find your own most of the time. It can be time-consuming but I have to say that being able to scroll through iTunes with album art for each track and album feels great. Additionally, it enables you to flip through your iTunes library by cover art, sort of like how you’d flip through vinyl in a collection, which is fun.

I know people who use playlists pretty extensively with iTunes. For me, there are usually only a few playlists, and they’re changing fairly regularly. For larger groups of songs that I want to play together, I typically do mixtapes (more on that later). Since I write about music here in Austin, I keep an Austin playlist for local music to listen to for review and consideration. I also have a playlist that I manage for putting music on my iPhone. Most of the rest of the playlists come and go — one you see there now is a mix I made for pal Hamish Robertson (“Negative”). “New Mix” is the playlist I have going for my next Flux-Rad mixtape. “2010″ is all the records, EPs and singles that have come out so far this year. Probably the most important playlist I keep in iTunes is my Inbox. When I first grab tracks from the web or get new albums to digest, they go right to the Inbox. These songs are in a folder on my desktop (also called Inbox). It’s there that I check out everything new. If I like it and decide to keep it in the library, it gets tagged properly, given album art, placed in its own titled folder and moved to the external hard drive. This also means that — because of how iTunes works — I’ll need to visit the main Music part of the app and search for that artist / album, delete the version that was located on the desktop and drag the version that’s now on the hard drive to the library. iTunes won’t automatically recognize that those files have been moved and next time it comes up on shuffle, I’ll get the exclamation point of doom. It’s easier to just remove the old info in the app and update with the new location of the files.

Above you see a small portion of the external hard drive and its library. As you can see, every record has its own folder with the artist, album title and year of release. Now, I know that I could just throw files on to a drive and let the meta-data do the organizing, but I like having everything organized this way. I prefer being able to see the files collected together by artist, nice and neat. I’ll admit, part of the reason I do it this way is a holdover pattern from the Winamp days, but so be it. Another good reason to do it this way is because of mix organizing.

But what about all the stray songs, mixtapes and other odds and ends that don’t fit into the nice artist / album organization technique? Well, there’s a way to do that, too.

Yep, I put every mix in its own folder too. This goes for collections that are actual mixtapes made by me or others, and it’s also including mixes I make myself that others might just include in a playlist. For example, I have a folder that is just my collection of ’80s and ’90s R&B. I have a folder that is a mixtape of just my ’80s singles. I have collections of vintage country music, Christmas songs and Motown, on and on. This section also includes compilations — like Old Glory’s All the President’s Men compilation from 1994. These mixes are organized together in iTunes as one album with a Various Artists ‘Album Artist’ field in the meta-data fields so they’ll play and display together as one album.

As you can see above, the album title will start with “VA – … ” for each collection I’ve made a folder for and transferred. Part of the reason I do this is to keep the mixes grouped together, but a more practical reason is so that if I do a search for “VA – ” in iTunes, I’ll get a complete list of all my mixes.

There is also a VA – Odds & Ends folder, which keeps all the stray singles and one-offs I enjoy but don’t need the entire album for. Those files are not grouped together by “VA”, they just appear on their own in the iTunes library. Every song that I end up liking but not caring much for the album (or older tracks that just don’t fit anywhere else, like a weird remix or novelty track). Once I toyed with the idea of keeping all these tracks grouped like a mix, but ultimately it just doesn’t make sense, they are all so diverse.

Basically my theory for keeping iTunes neat and organized is all based on albums, because typically that is how I prefer to listen to things. For people who aren’t as concerned with having a digital album collection, my way might not make sense. There are some bits about my method that can be arduous, but it’s the easiest way I’m aware of to keep things clean and save my digital library from becoming an unmanageable mess. Naturally I miss things, which means that every couple of months I’ll scroll through iTunes and do some pruning or organizing. Call me a weirdo, but I enjoy it. If you have any questions about how I do this or some tips for me, I’m all ears!

Comments for this entry

I, too, use Grouping for record labels and always wondered why there was no proper Record Label field.

Awesome post. I never thought of using the “grouping” field like that. I’ll employ that this weekend.

I’m surprised you don’t put smart playlists to use more frequently. For example, you could have a smart playlist for “2010″ that looks for any music with “2010″ in the “year” tag. As long as your meta-data is up to snuff, it’ll auto-magically make a playlist for you by year. I also do this for new music. I have a “Recently Added” playlist that has everything that I’ve imported within the last 10 days.

Thanks again for the nerdy music post.

Love the post Paige.

Personally I use the Grouping field to help further categorize music. This allows me to classify music as “LIVE” or “OLD” (i.e. Classic) or “BLUES” without having to create multiple Genre tags. Years ago I created tons of Genre tags, but the problem that arose was there wasn’t a way of just listening to “Rock” music in general. It’s not very specific. I’ve toyed with the idea of adding labels into the Grouping field but haven’t yet. I think just the initial task of labeling everything holds me back at this point.

One thing I do is rate my music as a listen to it. I’ve programmed some quick keyboard shortcuts using Quicksilver (Mac App) that allows me to instantly give any song playing 1-5 stars. As I rate music, it makes it into a number of playlists that I cycle through. The biggest playlist being my “Station” playlist, which utilizes about 2 semesters of radio programming classes in college to develop a personal radio station. Anyone with radio experience knows how most stations develop their playlists, keeping lists of songs that are considered all-time favs (my 5′s), gold tracks (my 4′s), decent tracks (my 3′s) and new tracks. Using varying amounts of each I developed smart playlist that shuffles through about 4 or 5 playlists.

I can provide some images and further explanation if you’re interested.

I’ve always used the Grouping field for record labels, too. And I completely clear the ‘Genre’ field in everything that goes into my library. I hate hate hate when people use that field. Also, I’ve never touched the Rating system & never plan to.

We share a lot of the same organization habits (viewing options, needing album art for everything, an ‘Inbox’ playlist, etc.) & love of nerding out over managing our library. The big difference I see is that I like to have iTunes copy files to my iTunes Media folder whenever I add anything to my library & then have iTunes also keep my iTunes media folder organized for me. Some people don’t like to do it this way b/c they feel it takes away too much of the control and personal preference. I disagree. The key is in the tagging. If you tag things a certain way, everything can be organized within the iTunes Media folder exactly the way you want it to be & everything ends up easy to find. For example…

For compilations, I leave the ‘Artist’ field tagged as the band that performs each song, but I select all the songs for the album and change the ‘Album Artist’ field to ‘Various Artists’ and tick off the ‘Part of a compilation’ box under Options.

But if it’s a mixtape, I leave that box unchecked and just change the ‘Album Artist’ field to the name of the person/website who put the mix together. Since iTunes’ automatic organization creates folders & sorts them based on the ‘Album Artist’ tag, all of my own mixes & all of my Elastic Heart, Flux=Rad, Mondo Salvo, Yewknee, etc. mixes have their own folder.

I find that to be the best system, personally. But I can certainly understand how if you’re already accustomed to doing it another way, it would be tough to make that lateral step towards a different way of organizing.

OMG Paige. I love this. I thoroughly enjoy your organizational method, even if I would never employ some factors of it myself. Since I have an opinion on everything nerdy, I’ll chime in here with a few ideas.

You file organization is too much work for me. iTunes itself has a pretty great method of auto organization. It works by itself and it’s easy enough to navigate. I’m comfortable with the idea that iTunes will simply handle all the media files and I’m free to do my organization strictly within iTunes. This is mostly because I’ve accepted that there is no perfect method of file organization. It drives me bonkers that if I have an studio album and a greatest hits album that contain the same song, the file has to be on my HDD twice; same recording, multiple files. I understand why it’s necessary, but it kills me.

You mention single songs in your post, but it’s never made clear just exacty you do with them. I’m wildly curious where you put those guilty pleasure singles.

There’s a secondary accomplishment to listing complications as “VA” in the Album Artist field. iTunes will you group compilations together, removing compilation-only artists from your library artists, but the same is not true for the iPhone (as of OS 3.1.3). The iPhone will however sort your artists by Album Artist, though the Artist tag will still display. Because all of your compilations begin with “VA,” all of your compilation-only artists will be listed in the Vs in your iPhone, essentially segregating them from your library artists. Neat! But I’d still like the option to remove them all together. OS4 perhaps?

I agree with Eric, I’m surprised you’re not using more Smart Playlists. I actually use one to keep my iPhone up to date since all my music doesn’t fit on it. I have an “iPhone” playlist that syncs, as well as a Smart Playlist of any label as music added within the last three months and not already included in the “iPhone” playlist. This does a few things: First it put anything new into my iPhone regardless of me remembering/wanting to add it to my “iPhone” playlist. If those additions aren’t something I’m really into, then they automatically disappear from my iPhone after three month upon my next sync. If I am into it, I can pull of the Smart Playlist to see anything that isn’t permanently synced to the phone, and easily drag it into the permanent “iPhone” playlist. I also have a non-syncing Smart Playlist for items three-to-four months old and not on the “iPhone” playlist, just incase I forget to move something and it expires, I can find it quickly to make it a permanent addition. For you, I could see this useful if you set up Smart Playlists for your favorite labels. They would automatically update anytime you added music on that label. Easy!

I’d really like to be more thorough with my genres. Let’s be honest not ALL of my music is from legitimate sources, and those ID3 genre tags can get ridiculous.

Last thing I’ll mention are the “Rating” stars. Obviously these are useful for picking favorites, if that’s what you would like to do. But those stars could arbitrarily mean whatever you’d like them to mean. One-star could mean it’s an Austin artist, two might mean you’ve used it in a mixtape before, three could mean…. well I dunno, but it’s a quickly alternative categorization system (if you only have five or less categories :-p ).

But yeah, great info. Fun and nerdy!

“You mention single songs in your post, but it’s never made clear just exacty you do with them. I’m wildly curious where you put those guilty pleasure singles.”

Brian – All those random singles go into the “Odds and Ends” folder I talk about above … Works out perfectly.

As for smart playlists, I think you guys have given me a reason to check it out. I’m thinking of smart playlists for year and decades happening … Nice!

James Baker

- iTunes won’t automatically recognize that those files have been moved and next time it comes up on shuffle, I’ll get the exclamation point of doom.

You probably know this, but iTunes will keep track of files that move, even outside its own directory. What you’re describing here is a copy to another volume, which means there are two copies of the file, and then a delete of the original, which is where iTunes gets understandably lost. (But this is the same for every application on a Mac.) iTunes has control over its own home folder, in which it can rename and move files itself. It’s perfectly happy with files outside that folder too, it just can’t rename or organize them, and they can be on many different volumes.

Marie

I also try to only listen to full albums, and when I can I divide them by vinyl side (so next to album it says [side 1] ect.) . I also use genres as a primary organizing tool. For albums I have found/ bought myself I put an m in front ie. mAlternative and for albums/mixes from friends I either put their initial in front if there is a substantial amount of music or mFriendsname for one or two album/mixes.

I never did find a good use for Grouping. For awhile i would put the name of the radio station in Nashville (my home) most likely to play the song. About 3 songs per album would have a grouping of some sort on them, usually the radio singles. Folk/Rock songs might have a grouping of “100.1″, classic rock songs “105.9″, top 40 songs “107.5″. Then I would have smart playlists that would play songs based on Grouping name and one smart playlist that listed every song where Grouping was not blank. Seemed to work pretty well.

Leave your comment

Please be polite. You can use these HTML tags: STRONG, A, BLOCKQUOTE, CODE